The Rev. Dr. Brandon Perrine
Proper 25 A
Matthew 22:34-40
October 25, 2026
When the Pharisees heard that [Jesus] had silenced the Sadducees, they gathered together, and one
of them, a lawyer, asked him a question to test him. “Teacher, which commandment in the law is the
greatest?” He said to him, “’You shall love the Lord your God with all your heart, and with all
your soul, and with all your mind.’ This is the greatest and first commandment. And a second is
like it: ‘You shall love your neighbor as yourself.’ On these two commandments hang all the law and
the prophets.”
o
Let’s be honest: Jesus could have said literally anything else and it would have been easier to do, wouldn’t it? Oh that he would have said, “Thou shalt not murder” or “Thou shalt not covet thy neighbor’s wife.” I got those covered! But Love? Love God, love self, and love neighbor? That is much, much more difficult.
Jesus’ priority of loves was hardly new with him, though. Rabbi Akiva called the command to love one’s neighbor the great principle of Torah. Rabbi Hillel, a generation before Jesus, had responded to a request for a summary of Torah by saying: “That which is hateful to you, do not do to your fellow—this is the whole Torah; the rest is commentary.” The very words that Jesus used come from the biblical books of Deuteronomy and Leviticus—traditionally attributed to Moses himself. Jesus’ own summary was deeply Jewish, and deeply biblical, and already widely acknowledged. But it was still just as hard back then as it is now.
With all our medical and technological and social advances, humans have yet to discover anything that makes it easier to love one another. Do you ever wonder why it’s just so hard to love others?
It might be helpful if we defined what we mean by the word love. Jesus isn’t suggesting that we should love our neighbors the way I love ice cream, or the way you love your partner, or the way we love pipe organ music. This kind of love has absolutely nothing to do with personal preference or intimate connection. This kind of love has everything to do with wanting the best for others and acting accordingly. This kind of love isn’t primarily an emotion; it’s a commitment expressed through action. This kind of love is a conscious choice to be made, irrespective of how we may or may not feel about the person in question. This is a love we choose to practice, in both words and deeds. And perhaps that’s why Jesus places these two commandments side by side. Loving our neighbors is one of the most meaningful ways we can express our love for God.
So, I’ll ask again, why do you think it’s so hard to love others?
Perhaps the easiest answer is that we don’t want to. I’ll be honest with you: there are people that I don’t want to love. Furthermore, I don’t really think that withholding my love from those particular people will make a whole heap of difference to them. But choosing to love them anyway—to want the best for them and act accordingly—just might change me. Just might make me a better person. Just might make me the better person that helps make someone else a better person. Who might, in turn, help someone else, and on and on until we’re all better people. But it’s a choice. We don’t have to want to love someone. We can choose not to love someone. Or we can choose to love them anyway.
Why else do you think it’s so hard to love others?
I wonder if it’s not also because we simply aren’t sure which others we’re supposed to love. Jesus used the word “neighbor.” So, who is my neighbor? According to Martin Luther, the 15th century priest-turned-reformer, “My neighbor is every person, especially those who need my help . . . Even if a person has done me some wrong, or has hurt me in any way, [they are] still a human being with flesh and blood. As long as a person remains a human being, so long [are they] to be an object of our love.”[1] Every. Person. It leaves very little for interpretation, but at least it’s easy to remember. And I happen to think Luther is exactly right on this point.
Every person is our neighbor regardless of who they voted for, or where they were born, or what gender they identify as, or who they love, or what color their skin is, or what they do for a living, or how much money is in their bank account, or who their friends are, or if their middle name is John. They are all our neighbors. And we are called to love them.
Can you think of any other reasons it’s so hard to love others, I wonder?
One reason I think I’d be remiss not to mention is that sometimes we may find it hard to love ourselves. As one evangelical pastor (Joyce Meyer) puts it, “You cannot give away something you don’t have in you. How can someone love another person if they don’t love themselves?” While we’ve all likely known people who didn’t think very highly of themselves, but still had a deep capacity to show love for others, Jesus envisions love of others rooted in love of self. And no matter what you’ve been told, you are worthy of love—especially your own.
But here’s something else I’ve been wondering about. We tend to think that we have to feel love before we can demonstrate it. That we have to become loving people before we can do loving things. But I’m not sure that’s how it works. Remember, this kind of love isn’t an emotion, it’s an action. Maybe sometimes we have to start with the doing. Maybe we have to choose to love someone before we actually feel anything resembling love for them. Maybe, somewhere along the way, the practice of loving changes us into loving people. And that is such a Jesus move—to call us to do the hardest thing, knowing that the doing of it might just make us better people.
I do want to add one word of caution, though. The distinction between acting and feeling isn’t meant to give us permission to hold on to hateful feelings. Jesus isn’t suggesting that we can disguise our contempt for someone by claiming to love the sinner while hating the sin. He’s not suggesting that we pretend to like someone we don’t. But neither is he giving us permission to cling to our resentment, our prejudices, or our contempt while congratulating ourselves for behaving lovingly.
I still wish Jesus had chosen an easier commandment. There are plenty of things I can promise never to do. But loving every person? That’s a tall order. And maybe that’s precisely the point. Because every time we choose to love someone we’d rather not, every time we choose kindness over contempt, compassion over indifference, or generosity over selfishness, we become just a little more loving ourselves. And perhaps, in time, we might even discover that loving our neighbors isn’t quite as difficult as it used to be. May it be so. Amen.
[1] Martin Luther. Commentary on Galatians, 1535.
